Cool Jobs: Keeping TV science honest | Science News for Students

Cool Jobs: Keeping TV science honest

Advisors for Bones, Chicago Med and The Big Bang Theory reveal their secrets
Sep 8, 2016 — 7:00 am EST
Sheldon Amy

Amy Farrah Fowler (played by Mayim Bialik) and Sheldon Cooper (played by Jim Parsons) eye equations on The Big Bang Theory. Advisor David Saltzberg makes sure that the pictured equations are right, along with most of the rest of the science on this show.

Michael Yarish/CBS

This is one in a series on careers in science, technology, engineering and mathematics made possible with generous support from Alcoa Foundation.

It takes a lot to gross out Donna Cline. As the science advisor for the Fox TV show Bones, she’s used to seeing real-looking mutilated corpses. But when live worms emerged from a fake intestine in an autopsy scene, she almost lost her lunch. “I’m okay with decomposing bodies — I’ve seen them for real. But I don’t like worms,” she confesses.

Cline pretty much loves everything about the job she’s had for the past 11 years. It’s something she shares with the other technical advisors you’ll meet in this story. They give you the inside scoop on what it takes to make TV science and medicine realistic. And they share some behind-the-scenes “cheats” that make popular shows seem more real than they are.

Here are some of the people who inject a dose of reality into make-believe.

Bones: Donna Cline

Cline has worked on Bones — a murder mystery and forensics drama — from the day it started. And, she says, “It’s incredibly entertaining for me to see how the science is woven into the drama.” She’s on the set whenever there’s a crime scene or lab research at the fictional Jeffersonian Institute. She also helps explain technical details to the actors. “I never know what’s going to happen next,” she says, “or what I’m going to be asked to do.”

Donna Cline
Bones’ technical advisor Donna Cline is also the show’s storyboard artist. Here, she draws a human skull.
Dean Hendler

Cline also works closely with the show’s writers on every script. First, the writers send her an outline several weeks ahead of filming. At this point, she starts “researching every detail in terms of forensics and anatomy.” Later, she meets with the people who lead departments such as makeup, visual effects and wardrobe to work out details. Then there’s a final meeting to make adjustments before shooting the scenes.

The writers are very open to Cline’s suggestions, she says. “I give them ideas, and they can run things by me.” One time, she told them about a spider bite infection that can cause bone injury. Sure enough, it showed up in the plot.

She also makes sure the right character is doing the right task. If it has to do with bones, it’s forensic anthropologist Temperance Brennan (played by Emily Deschanel). If it involves tissues and organs, it’s pathologist Camille Saroyan (played by Tamara Taylor).

Cline works closely with the cast, showing them how to use tools properly. For each episode, she provides a guide to science terms. She lists those terms scene-by-scene and alphabetically, with an illustration of each item. As a former medical illustrator, that’s both easy for her and fun.

Emily Deschanel and Tamara Taylor
Temperance Brennan (played by Emily Deschanel) and Camille Saroyan (played by Tamara Taylor) hunt for evidence at a crime scene on Bones.
Patrick McElhenney/FOX

As a child, she always “wanted to know how things worked biologically.” She later got a master’s degree in biomedical illustration. Along the way, she dissected cadavers and drew tissues and organs. She even illustrated a surgical textbook. She then became a storyboard artist and medical advisor for movies. Today she does both jobs on Bones.

For reference, Cline checks a huge library on science and forensics. It includes books on gunshot wounds, embalming and blood-splatter patterns. If these can’t answer a question, she has a network of specialists to call upon.

Cline loves being able to inject cutting-edge science into TV shows, but only as long as “it works for the storyline.” Sometimes, she admits, she and the writers have to make some sort of compromise. “But,” she adds, “it’s always well-thought-out compromises that aren’t unbelievable or tacky.”

A bit of an exaggeration?

So where do they stretch the truth? Let’s start with the characters’ jobs.

In reality, Cline says, forensic anthropologists who work for a medical examiner’s office would spend their time in the field, retrieving evidence and bodies. It’s not realistic to have Brennan working so closely with the FBI on such a regular basis, Cline says.

More and more, real crime labs are using the kind of computer-assisted facial reconstruction that Angela Montenegro (played by Michaela Conlin) does on the show. Cline says the technology probably wouldn’t produce faces that are nearly as precise as the show suggests. “But,” she adds, “I don’t doubt that real life will catch up.”

Emily Deschanel
Don’t worry — the grisly skeleton Brennan (Emily Deschanel) is examining in the lab is a prop.
Patrick McElhenney/FOX

In the real world, it takes much longer to get answers about evidence than it does on TV. DNA analysis can take weeks, Cline notes. But on the show, “We get them back in a couple of hours.”

Jack Hodgins (played by T.J. Thyne) is an insect expert, or entomologist. He analyzes maggots on cadavers to find out when someone died — which is actually possible. “But we don’t show the whole procedure,” she says. Most people would find the details of evidence analysis long and tedious. “We’d put everyone to sleep,” Cline suspects.

The insect larvae in those scenes are sometimes real and sometimes not. Maggots that need to move in a scene are mealworms; ones that don’t are grains of orzo. “We sometimes use coffee beans for bugs,” Cline says.

Another substitute involves skeletons. “The bones are resin,” she reveals. “We buy them from a company that molds them from real bones. We can order males, females, teenagers, kids.” They can even ask for bones from different races.

Sometimes, for effect, fire victims’ bodies are burned more than they would be in real life. At other times, the wackiest things are absolutely real. Cline remembers a Bones crime scene showing a tree that blew over, revealing a skeleton in its roots. “The tree had grown over the buried body,” Cline says. “That really happened.”

Chicago Med: Andrew Dennis

Combining real medicine and make-believe medicine makes life interesting for doctor Andrew Dennis. He’s a trauma and burn surgeon at Cook County Hospital in Chicago, Ill. He’s also the medical advisor to the NBC series Chicago Med.

Dennis doesn’t just oversee the many medical procedures on the show. He also meets with the writers to review scripts and tweak them for medical accuracy. His job is to make sure “the storylines are appropriate for the characters,” he says, “and are as real as possible.”

Andrew Dennis
Chicago Med medical advisor Dr. Andrew Dennis (left) calls in cardiac specialist Dr. Doug Smego (right) for help with tricky heart surgeries.
Courtesy of Andrew Dennis

This part-time job puts him on set about three days a week. He makes sure anything photographic — including x-rays — looks right. He also ensures that the actors move in the right way during surgery scenes. In fact, he choreographs the surgeries. Unless a scene involves delivering a baby, that is. Then, his wife Melissa Dennis, an obstetrician-gynecologist, takes over. He may also call in specialists to help with other things outside his comfort zone, such as brain and heart operations.

Dennis discusses story ideas with colleagues at his hospital. Some ideas come right from the headlines. They may be “unique cases,” he says, “not something most doctors have ever seen.” The case of an icicle piercing a patient’s head is a good (and all-too-true) example.

“Our rule is that if it’s published somewhere, it’s fair game, as farfetched as it might be,” he says.

In surgical scenes, the show’s extras are real medical students, doctors and nurses. And Bobbin Bergstrom is on the set full-time to supervise. She’s a nurse and medical consultant “in charge of making sure the details work,” notes Dennis. “We are a team.”

Early on, he put the cast through a three-day “medical boot camp.” The actors learned everything from how to give patients stitches and IVs to how to put on sterile gloves and do CPR. Guest actors go through a modified form of the boot camp.  

But despite everything Dennis does to be medically accurate, there’s a lot that just can’t be done on TV.

Chicago Med
Dennis (center) turns actors Colin Donnell (Dr. Connor Rhodes) and Nick Gehlfuss (Dr. Will Halstead) into smooth operators on the set of Chicago Med.
Courtesy of Andrew Dennis

As you might expect, “You can’t put real needles in actors. All that is done artificially.” And if the task calls for something very technical, “We’ll do it as an ‘insert,’ where you’ll see my hands or one of my colleagues’ hands,” says Dennis. “If it looks like we’re sticking a needle into someone’s groin, there’s usually a small prosthetic over that area (and a safety plate behind it).” And those needles don’t really go into someone’s skin: they’re retractable. “Safety on the set is paramount,” Dennis says. “We use dull knife blades, and defibrillators are [modified] so no one gets shocked.”

He works with the special-effects department to create all of these elements and make sure they’re right for the surgery shown. In all operations, the organs are made of silicone, and the blood is a mix of corn syrup and food coloring.

In real operating rooms, surgeons and nurses wear hats and masks. “But producers want to see actors’ faces, so we cheat that,” says Dennis. For the same reason, TV shows lower the drape that normally would cover a patient’s face.

Not surprisingly, things happen a lot faster on Chicago Med than they do in real life. Lab results come back in minutes. Surgery patients wake up quickly. “We do what we have to for the dramatic needs,” Dennis says. But he estimates that the show is 85 percent accurate. “For a medical drama, I think that’s pretty high.”

The Big Bang Theory: David Saltzberg

Since 2007, CBS’ The Big Bang Theory has poked fun at the quirkier side of scientists. Physicists Sheldon Cooper (played by Jim Parsons) and Leonard Hofstadter (Johnny Galecki), aerospace engineer Howard Wolowitz (Simon Helberg) and astrophysicist Raj Koothrappali (Kunal Nayyar) provide plenty of laughs. But there’s real science behind the humor on this sitcom. And from the start, David Saltzberg has been the man responsible for getting it right.

David Saltzberg
In his job as The Big Bang Theory’s science advisor, David Saltzberg writes all the formulas you see on the show. Trust us, they’re real!
Michael Yarish/CBS

“Sometimes it’s as simple as writing some equations on the whiteboards in the boys’ apartment,” he says. At other times, “it’s an experiment they might be doing or an invention they might be developing.” And he should know. Salzberg teaches physics and astronomy at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Saltzberg isn’t on set every day, just on days the show is taped. But if there’s a lot of science in an episode, he says, “I’ll come to a rehearsal and make sure the dialog, diagrams or pictures are right.”

The scientist stays up to date with news from the American Physical Society so he can make story suggestions. They need to be factual, but not too out-there. “The characters live in our world,” Saltzberg says. When the writers come up with an idea that doesn’t ring true, he says, “I give options.” In one case, when he explained to the writers that a theory wasn’t well established, “the next version of the script had them disproving the idea.”

If a script involves the life sciences, he defers to Mayim Bialik. She’s the real-life neuroscientist who plays Amy Farrah Fowler. “She makes sure we don’t make any mistakes. And I certainly don’t need to tell her how to pronounce anything!” He says that he doesn’t have to tell Jim Parsons either, despite the complicated scientific speeches he often has to make.

Cameo appearances by real scientists make The Big Bang Theory more authentic. Guests have included astrophysicist Neil DeGrasse Tyson, black-hole expert Stephen Hawking and engineer Bill Nye the Science Guy. But Saltzberg admits to some minor cheats.

For example, the California Institute of Technology is a real university — but the way it works on the show isn’t realistic. Viewers never see the characters’ supervisors, Saltzberg points out. And in most real science projects, researchers would be working together on teams, not working alone as they do on the show.

Sheldon Cooper (played by Jim Parsons) and Leonard Hofstadter (played by Johnny Galecki) study physics equations on The Big Bang Theory.
Michael Yarish/CBS

Lasers are another example. In real life, you usually can’t see a laser’s beam. But that would not be visually interesting. “So you show the laser beam for the audience,” Salzberg says.

This physicist has taught at UCLA for 20 years, and now often lets the show borrow his school’s equipment and materials. Sometimes his colleagues and students even get to visit the set. For Saltzberg, moonlighting in show business is a lot of fun. Once, a University of Hawaii astronomer even surprised Saltzberg and The Big Bang Theory cast and creators by naming asteroids after them.

Social media weighs in

No matter how closely the advisors scrutinize the scripts, mistakes will happen.

Donna Cline remembers a line about a “fractured cerebellum.” The problem: That is medically impossible. The cerebellum is soft tissue, so it can’t be cracked. The script should have called it “damaged” or “injured” instead. “I don’t know how that happened,” Cline says. But she sure heard about it afterward.

Andrew Dennis welcomes input from social media. “We know that some of the things we tackle are controversial,” he says. That’s because the show wants to encourage discussion. It’s one more thing Dennis has to think about, besides accuracy.

David Salzberg recalls the script from an early episode that mentioned a real scientist named Amos Dolbear, but called him Emil by mistake. Salzberg still feels bad about it. But he’s glad that the Internet and social media exist now to keep technical advisors on their toes.

“Everyone can rewind and freeze frame and go into chat rooms and make fun of you if you get something wrong,” Dennis says. As a result, “Today, you’re hard pressed to find a show that doesn’t try to get it right.”

Power Words

(for more about Power Words, click here)

aerospace  A research field devoted to the study of Earth’s atmosphere and the space beyond or to aircraft that travel in the atmosphere and space.

anatomy (adj. anatomical) The study of the organs and tissues of animals. Or the characterization of the body or parts of the body on the basis of its structure and tissues. Scientists who work in this field are known as anatomists.

asteroid  A rocky object in orbit around the sun. Most orbit in a region that falls between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. Astronomers refer to this region as the asteroid belt.

astronomy The area of science that deals with celestial objects, space and the physical universe. People who work in this field are called astronomers.

bug The slang term for an insect. Sometimes it’s even used to refer to a germ.

cadaver  A human corpse.

cerebellum   A region in the back of the brain that controls muscle movement.

cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)     A first-aid technique that involves performing chest compressions and mouth-to-mouth breathing on a patient.

decomposition   The process by which compounds in once-living things are broken down and returned to the environment; the process by which something decays or rots.

defibrillator   A device that delivers electric current to the heart to restore its proper rhythm.

digital facial reconstruction    A method that forensic anthropologists use to interpret the features of a skull and learn about its age, sex and ancestry.

dissecting    Dissection is the act of disassembling something to examine how it is put together. In biology, this means opening up animals or plants to view their anatomy.

DNA (short for deoxyribonucleic acid) A long, double-stranded and spiral-shaped molecule inside most living cells that carries genetic instructions. It is built on a backbone of phosphorus, oxygen, and carbon atoms. In all living things, from plants and animals to microbes, these instructions tell cells which molecules to make.

entomology   The scientific study of insects. One who does this is an entomologist.

fiction   (adj. fictional) An idea or a story that is made-up, not a depiction of real events.

forensic anthropology    A field of research that seeks to identify the sex, age, ancestry, or other characteristics identified in skeletal remains or other biological tissue. People who work in this field are known as forensic anthropologists. They use scientific techniques to study historical artifacts and settings and to aid in criminal investigations.

forensics    The use of science and technology to investigate and solve crimes.

infection    A disease that can spread from one organism to another.

IV   Short for “intravenous,” an IV delivers a medication or other liquid directly into a vein.

larva  (plural: larvae) An immature life stage of an insect, which often has a distinctly different form as an adult. (Sometimes used to describe such a stage in the development of fish, frogs and other animals.)

laser  A device that generates an intense beam of coherent light of a single color. Lasers are used in drilling and cutting, alignment and guidance, in data storage and in surgery.

maggot    The larva of a fly.

master’s degree    A university graduate degree for advanced study, usually requiring a year or two of work, for people who have already graduated from college.

medical examiner   A government official, usually a medical doctor, charged with investigating suspicious deaths and injuries.

medical illustrator     A professional artist who has studied both the life sciences and visual arts. Medical illustrators create anatomical illustrations for books, articles, and computer animations.

neuroscience     Science that deals with the structure or function of the brain and other parts of the nervous system. Researchers in this field are known as neuroscientists.

obstetrician-gynecologist   (abbrev. OB-GYN) A doctor who deals with female reproductive health, pregnancy and the delivery of babies.

organ  (in biology) Various parts of an organism that perform one or more particular functions. For instance, an ovary is an organ that makes eggs, the brain is an organ that interprets nerve signals and a plant’s roots are organs that take in nutrients and moisture.

pathologist    Someone who studies disease and how it affects people or other infected organisms.

physics   The scientific study of the nature and properties of matter and energy. Classical physics is an explanation of the nature and properties of matter and energy that relies on descriptions such as Newton’s laws of motion. Quantum physics, a field of study which emerged later, is a more accurate way of explaining the motions and behavior of matter. A scientist who works in that field is known as a physicist.

prosthetic    Adjective that refers to a prosthesis, an artificial device that replaces a missing body part. Such a prosthetic limb, for example, would replace parts of an arm or leg. These replacement parts usually substitute for tissues missing due to injury, disease or birth defects.

silicone  Heat-resistant substances that can be used in many different ways, including the rubber-like materials that provide a waterproof seal around windows and in aquariums. Some silicones serve as grease-like lubricants in cars and trucks. Most silicones, a type of molecule known as a polymer, are built around long chains of silicon and oxygen atoms.

social media     Internet-based media, such as Facebook, Twitter and Tumblr, that allow people to connect with each other (often anonymously) and to share information.

storyboard     (in movie-making and television)  A series of small drawings, drawn in sequence, used to visually map out a scene in terms of action, camera angle and storytelling.

technical advisor     (in movie-making, television and theatre)   An expert who helps with production of a film or TV show to make sure everything is accurate.

tissue     Any of the distinct types of material, comprised of cells, which make up animals, plants or fungi. Cells within a tissue work as a unit to perform a particular function in living organisms. Different organs of the human body, for instance, often are made from many different types of tissues. And brain tissue will be very different from bone or heart tissue.

trauma  (adj. traumatic) Serious injury or damage to an individual’s body or mind.