Are fidget spinners tools or toys? | Science News for Students

Are fidget spinners tools or toys?

The wildly popular gadgets may help some people focus
Jun 1, 2017 — 7:10 am EST
fidget spinner spinning

Fidget spinners are fun and some think they might benefit the brain.

L. S. Hwang

Andrew Bonini was stuck inside at school on a sweltering day. To get his mind off the heat, the eighth grader took out his fidget spinner — a flat, palm-sized gadget with three arms that spins on a ball bearing. The Connecticut teen flicked it and watched it spin around and around. It whirred quietly.

fidget spinner
Andrew Bonini shows off his fidget spinner. He’s allowed to use it at school as long as it doesn’t distract others.
Christine Bonini

Andrew is 14. His younger sisters each have their own fidget spinners. Twelve-year-old Ava is teaching herself a trick. “I’ll be holding it and spinning it on my pointer finger, then I try to balance it on my middle finger while it’s spinning.” Allie, who’s nine, has been trying to balance hers on her nose as it spins. “It’s not easy,” she notes.

Silly tricks aside, all three siblings feel their spinners are more than mere toys. Andrew thinks the gadget helps him reduce stress and boredom. Allie tends to take hers out when she’s alone in her bedroom and feeling upset or anxious. “If I can play with it for five minutes, it helps me not be as worried,” she says.

The Bonini kids are part of the fidget spinner craze that is sweeping across the United States and other parts of the world. People of all ages are spinning an array of devices that come in all sorts of shapes and colors. The spinners follow a long line of toy fads, from hula hoops to Pokémon cards and silly bands.

But fidget spinners may be more than just a toy. Some websites that sell them have made sweeping health claims. They say the spinners can help relieve stress, anxiety or even the symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). At the same time, some schools have banned the gadgets for being too distracting. So, are spinners annoying toys or therapeutic tools? It turns out, they can be both.

Story continues below video.

Some people have figured out how to do plenty of tricks with fidget spinners.
Spinnercraft, www.spinnercraft.com

Spinner inspiration

Years before the current spinner craze took off, inventor Catherine Hettinger of Winter Park, Fla., was going through a difficult summer. She has a disorder called myasthenia gravis. In this condition, instructions from the brain can fail to make it to the muscles. People like Hettinger can therefore have trouble moving their arms and hands. Her daughter, Sara, was seven at the time. “I couldn’t pick up my daughter's toys and couldn’t play with her,” the woman recalls.

Whenever Hettinger hears of a problem, though, no matter how large or small, she immediately starts imagining devices to fix it. She and her daughter worked together to design and build something they could play with together. “We toyed with all kinds of kitchen stuff and other household objects. I could crumple up newspaper and use tape to think in three dimensions,” she says. 

spinning toy
Catherine Hettinger’s granddaughter Chloe plays with a classic fidget spinner. “Once people use it they love it,” says Hettinger.
Catherine Hettinger

The result of all that tinkering was a small plastic disc that could be spun on the tip of a finger. In 1993, Hettinger filed for a patent on the spinning toy and started selling it at craft fairs. (A patent gives a person or company exclusive rights to make, sell or use an invention.) She also pitched the device to toy companies. Before a meeting with the vice president and lead designer of one company, Hettinger found herself playing with the spinner. She says, “It helped to calm me down.”

Unfortunately, none of the companies decided to produce her toy. And a patent doesn’t last forever. Hettinger eventually let hers lapse. Though she continued to sell the spinners at craft fairs and online, the idea of a finger spinner no longer belonged to her alone. Yet she’s thrilled that a variation on her idea has now become so popular.

The fidget spinners that most people have now don’t look much like Hettinger’s original. Hers looked a bit like a sun hat or a flying saucer that would balance atop a fingertip. Most of today’s spinners have three arms and spin for a longer time on tiny ball bearings. People have gotten very creative with new sizes and shapes for these spinners.

Since last fall, for instance, Joe Garritano has been making spinners in his garage. “It looks like a mad scientist's laboratory,” he quips. Some of his hand-made all-metal spinners sell for more than $100. Most of his customers are collectors who view the spinners as works of art. Others buy them for a very different reason: therapy.

Story continues below video.

A milling machine cuts out a fidget spinner in Joe Garritano’s workshop. This machine is a type of robot that follows custom instructions to cut out a specific shape.
Joe Garritano, Steampunk Spinners, www.steampunkspinners.com

Fidget to focus

Garritano’s high-end collectibles, Hettinger’s classic spinner and the Boninis’ three-spoked fidget spinner are all part of a much broader category of toys that therapists sometimes use as tools for their patients. There are balls to squish, putty to stretch, smooth stones to rub, necklaces or bracelets to chew on and a multitude of other objects. Therapists refer to these items as “sensory manipulatives” or “fidgets.” The patient uses the fidget to excite one or more senses. This typically helps them either to calm down or become more alert.

350_phat_boy_spinner.png
Joe Garritano makes many different kinds of fidget spinners in his workshop, but this “phat boy” is his favorite. He went through more than 20 prototypes to get its design just right. “To me, it's truly magical,” he says. It also costs $99!
Joe Garritano, Steampunk Spinners, www.steampunkspinners.com

“Fidget tools provide us with subtle movement and touch inputs that can help calm our bodies and keep our minds attentive, alert and focused,” says Claire Heffron. She is an occupational therapist in Cleveland, Ohio. (An occupational therapist helps a person with a disorder or disability learn to perform daily tasks.)

Garritano estimates that two or three in every 10 of his customers bought their fidget spinners to help combat stress or anxiety or to improve focus. “The entire executive officer crew on a navy warship has them,” he says. They were a gift from their senior officer.

Varleisha Gibbs has recommended fidgets for therapy many times. She is an occupational therapist at Wesley College in Dover, Del. One student she worked with was constantly moving and touching things on other kids’ desks. She suggested a stress ball. “We Velcroed it underneath the desk,” she says. This helped the student keep his body in his own space. “He could get what he was seeking through touch, without being a distraction.”

Clearly, fidget devices are nothing new, notes Julie Schweitzer. She is a scientist at the University of California, Davis. A psychologist, she studies ways to diagnose and treat ADHD. People with this disorder have trouble paying attention and often move constantly or act impulsively. In some kids with this disorder, she explains, moving or fidgeting seems to increase their ability to pay attention.

Schweitzer tested this in a study published in 2015. Her team recruited 44 kids between the ages of 10 and 17. Twenty-six of the volunteers had ADHD. The others had no diagnosed disorders. They served as a control group. All of the kids completed an attention task. Each sat at a computer and viewed rows of arrows. In each row, they had to quickly identify which way the central arrow was pointing. Meanwhile, the kids all wore a device on their ankles. It tracked their motion.

The researchers didn’t ask the kids to move or to stay still. The kids simply knew they were to complete the task. For those with ADHD, the more they moved, the better they performed. But the amount of movement didn’t make a difference for the control group.

The study didn’t explain why movement helps kids with ADHD focus. But Schweitzer suspects that it’s similar to rubbing your face to wake up when you’re feeling tired. “I think the movement makes them more alert,” she says. As their attention starts to drift, a leg jiggle or foot tap seems to help rein them back in.

Getting distracted

Both Gibbs and Schweitzer agree that fidget spinners could help some kids with specific sensory needs. But a fidget spinner isn’t a magic cure. “It’s not for everyone,” says Gibbs.

Moreover, Schweitzer worries that the spinners may make it more difficult for some kids to focus. Students with ADHD get distracted very easily, she says. If other kids have spinners out at their desks at school, the student with ADHD will likely be watching the spinner and not the teacher.

Someone’s own spinner may distract as well, especially if it’s new. Kids may impulsively stop their work to spin it. They may use the spinner as a way to tune out the lesson. “You put a bright shiny toy in front of somebody” and what would you expect, asks Schweitzer? “Would they rather do that or read a history assignment?”

Fidget spinners regularly distract kids without ADHD as well. That can explain what’s behind recent school classroom bans on the devices.

370_inline_SpinnersAwaitingShipping.png
Fidget spinners come in all shapes, sizes and colors. These spinners are all handmade from copper, aluminum, brass and other metals.
Joe Garritano, Steampunk Spinners, www.steampunkspinners.com

In effective fidget therapy, the tool is integrated into students’ daily routines. It’s an activity someone practices until they don’t think about it anymore. A therapist with special training can help people discover what type of fidget tool might best meet their specific needs, says Gibbs. That tool, though, will be just one small part of a larger treatment plan that may include medication and other forms of therapy.

And a fidget spinner may not be the right choice for many kids with ADHD or other disorders that affect the senses. The spinner provides mainly visual feedback and only requires the movement of a few fingers. That may be fun or even relaxing. Still, what a child often may really need is the opportunity to stand, stretch or take a walk, explains Schweitzer.

Gibbs recommends wall push-ups and yoga poses. She also laments the fact that many schools have cut the amount of time kids spend at recess or in gym classes. Andrew Bonini, for instance, only has gym two out of every six school days. 

Movement may be essential for many children with sensory disorders, but it’s important for everyone. Fidget spinners may help relieve some squirminess, but they won’t take the place of real exercise. “Kids are meant to move and to experience the world around them using their senses,” says Heffron in Ohio. She argues that “the more we can build opportunities for movement and sensory input into their school day, the better.”

Power Words

anxiety     A nervous reaction to events causing excessive uneasiness and apprehension. People with anxiety may even develop panic attacks.

array     A broad and organized group of objects. Sometimes they are instruments placed in a systematic fashion to collect information in a coordinated way. Other times, an array can refer to things that are laid out or displayed in a way that can make a broad range of related things, such as colors, visible at once.

attention deficit hyperactivity disorder    (ADHD) This is a disorder characterized by not being able to focus or pay attention, being physically overactive, not being able to control behavior, or a combination of these.

control     A part of an experiment where there is no change from normal conditions. The control is essential to scientific experiments. It shows that any new effect is likely due only to the part of the test that a researcher has altered. For example, if scientists were testing different types of fertilizer in a garden, they would want one section of it to remain unfertilized, as the control. Its area would show how plants in this garden grow under normal conditions. And that gives scientists something against which they can compare their experimental data.

diagnose     To analyze clues or symptoms in the search for their cause. The conclusion usually results in a diagnosis — identification of the causal problem or disease.

disorder     (in medicine) A condition where the body does not work appropriately, leading to what might be viewed as an illness. This term can sometimes be used interchangeably with disease.

distraction     Any event or situation that draws someone’s attention away from whatever had been his or her main focus. Distractions can be external events, such as sounds or sights; or they can be internal events, such as thoughts or emotions.

feedback     A process or combination of processes that propel or exaggerate a change in some direction. For instance, as the cover of Arctic ice disappears with global warming, less of the sun’s warming energy will be reflected back into space. This will serve to increase the rate of Earth’s warming. That warming might trigger some feedback (like sea-ice melting) that fosters additional warming.

metal     Something that conducts electricity well, tends to be shiny (reflective) and malleable (meaning it can be reshaped with heat and not too much force or pressure). 

muscle     A type of tissue used to produce movement by contracting its cells, known as muscle fibers. Muscle is rich in protein, which is why predatory species seek prey containing lots of this tissue.

myasthenia gravis     This chronic autoimmune disease weakens muscles related to moving the body (especially the arms and legs) and lungs. The term for the disorder has Latin and Greek origins, meaning grave (as in severe) muscle weakness. There is no cure for this disease, which disrupts the transmission of nerve communications to muscles.

occupational therapist     Someone who works with patients who have some disability to help them learn (or relearn) how to perform daily activities (such as eating and dressing themselves) and to promote their general healthy well-being. Despite their name, people in this field do not necessarily deal with adult workers. Their patients can be anyone, from school-age children to the elderly.

patent     A legal document that gives inventors control over how their inventions — including devices, machines, materials, processes and substances — are made, used and sold for a set period of time. Currently in the United States, this runs 20 years from the date you first file for the patent. The U.S. government only grants patents to inventions shown to be unique.

plastic     Any of a series of materials that are easily deformable; or synthetic materials that have been made from polymers (long strings of some building-block molecule) that tend to be lightweight, inexpensive and resistant to degradation.

psychologist     A scientist or mental-health professional who studies the human mind, especially in relation to actions and behaviors. 

sibling     An offspring that shares the same parents (with its brother or sister).

stress     (in psychology) A mental, physical, emotional or behavioral reaction to an event or circumstance

subtle     Some feature that may be important, but can be hard to see or describe. For instance, the first cellular changes that signal the start of a cancer may be visible but subtle — small and hard to distinguish from nearby healthy tissues.

symptom     A physical or mental indicator generally regarded to be characteristic of a disease. Sometimes a single symptom — especially a general one, such as fever or pain — can be a sign of any of many different types of injury or disease.

therapy     (adj. therapeutic) Treatment intended to relieve or heal a disorder.

tool     An object that a person or other animal makes or obtains and then uses to carry out some purpose such as reaching food, defending itself or grooming.

NGSS: 

  • MS-ETS1-3

Citation

Journal: T.A. Hartano et al. A trial-by-trial analysis reveals more intense physical activity is associated with better cognitive control performance in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Child Neuropsychology. Vol. 22, Issue 5, 2016, p. 618. doi: 10.1080/09297049.2015.1044511.