Strange lake belches flammable gas in the high Arctic | Science News for Students

Strange lake belches flammable gas in the high Arctic

Lake Esieh is spewing vast amounts of methane — a potent greenhouse gas
Apr 25, 2019 — 6:45 am EST
an animated image showing a researcher igniting methane escaping from a frozen lake

Methane, a highly flammable gas, gets trapped under the ice of some Arctic lakes in winter. If a hole is punched through the ice, the escaping gas can be lit into a fireball.

University of Alaska Fairbanks

September 8, 2017, was an exciting date for Katey Walter Anthony. On this cool, windless evening she first visited Alaska’s Lake Esieh. Few people visit this remote stretch of wilderness. It is covered in tundra and scraggly spruce trees. Thousands of lakes dot the region. But Walter Anthony quickly realized that this lake was strange. As her boat glided across it, she came to a place where the water seemed to be boiling.

The water wasn’t warm. But it roiled and fizzed. Bubbles of all sizes streamed up, popping at the surface. One bubble, as large as a softball, gave off a loud bloonk as it ruptured. The bubbles covered a swath of the lake larger than a football field. And they rose with such force that they slowly pushed her boat to the side.

Walter Anthony leaned over the edge of the boat and collected some bubbles in a bottle. Then she struck a match and opened the bottle to release the gas she had just collected. The gas caught fire!

The yellow-tipped flame that danced over the bottle confirmed her suspicion. It showed that the lake was gurgling out a flammable gas, called methane. Each molecule (CH4) contains one atom of carbon bonded to four atoms of hydrogen.

As a potent greenhouse gas, methane can absorb radiation from the sun, warming the atmosphere. Methane, along with carbon dioxide, is a major source of global warming. Later calculations would show that this little lake was belching out lots of this gas — some 2,000 kilograms (4,400 pounds) each day.

Walter Anthony works at the University of Alaska in Fairbanks. She’s a limnologist, a scientist who studies lakes. To date, she has studied more than 300 of them in the Arctic. Many give off methane. But Lake Esieh was different. She could hear a deep-throated gurgling as bubbles shoved their way up, violently, through the mud at the bottom of the lake. “The sound was really amazing,” she says. It was coming from deep below her boat. “I’d never heard that before.”

methane bubbles float to the surface of Lake Esieh
The water appears to boil as methane bubbles up and out of Alaska’s Lake Esieh.
K. Walter Anthony

Scientists believe that the Arctic could release large amounts of methane over the next 100 years. The gas is naturally released as frozen soil, called permafrost, warms up and thaws. And some scientists worry that this methane will cause the world to warm more quickly than they had predicted.

Walter Anthony has spent nearly 20 years trying to understand this threat. She is trying to measure how much methane is coming out of warming Arctic lakes. And to her, Lake Esieh could be a warning. If other lakes respond the same way, the Arctic could be poised to burble out far more methane than anyone had expected. “We don’t even know how much gas is down there,” she says. “It’s a wild card.”

For that reason, it’s important to understand what’s happening at Lake Esieh.

Rotting mush

Permafrost covers 22 million square kilometers (8.5 million square miles) of territory across the north of Alaska, Canada, Europe and Asia. That’s an area larger than the United States and Canada combined. This frozen soil is rich in organic matter — the remains of plants that lived hundreds or thousands of years ago.

a map showing where permafrost is located in the Arctic
Permafrost, shown in various shades of purple, covers 22 million square kilometers (8.5 million square miles) of territory in the Arctic. It could become a major source of methane as it thaws.
Philippe Rekacewicz, UNEP/GRID-Arendal

These dead plants froze before they could fully decay. But as that permafrost now thaws, single-celled microbes have begun dining on those plant remains. They break down the dead stuff into mush, like kitchen scraps in a compost heap. Along the way, the microbes exhale methane and another carbon-based gas, carbon dioxide (CO2).

Scientists have long known that melting permafrost would release these gases. What has not been clear is how much might come out and how quickly. People are especially concerned about methane. Over a period of 100 years, it absorbs more than 20 times as much heat, gram for gram, as carbon dioxide does. Once in the atmosphere, methane slowly turns into carbon dioxide — also a greenhouse gas.

Walter Anthony has been figuring out just how much methane Arctic lakes are spewing. She started in 2002, while she was working toward her PhD at the University of Alaska. Back then, she was spending much of her time in Siberia, in northeast Russia.

Thawing permafrost can make the ground sag. These low spots fill with water — forming what are called “thermokarst” lakes. Walter Anthony saw tiny bubbles of methane bubbling up as she paddled her boat across one of these Siberian lakes, called Shuchi. But she could never anticipate where a bubble would emerge. So she couldn’t catch or measure them.

Starry sky

She got some advice from an ecologist at the Northeast Science Station in Chersky, Russia. This Sergey Zimov suggested that she try a new approach: Wait until winter freezes the lake over. The ice might trap methane bubbles, showing her where the gas was accumulating.

In October 2002, she donned a down jacket and headed out into the cold. She shoveled snow off a strip of lake ice, then poured water onto it. This smoothed the ice so that she could see through it into the lake below.

Methane gets trapped under the ice of some Arctic lakes in winter. If a hole is punched through the ice, the escaping gas can be lit into a fireball, as in this video.
University of Alaska Fairbanks/YouTube

“It was like looking at a starry night sky,” she says. The white gas bubbles stood out against the dark background of the water below. For the first time, she realized that most of the bubbles were coming up in very specific places — and always the same places. Now she knew where those places were.

She used a crowbar to chip holes in the ice. (She had the help of a large fellow named Dmitri Draluk, who also worked as a local firefighter, preacher and bodybuilder.) She and Draluk inserted bottles, with upside down funnels, to collect the gas that was bubbling up. They kept the bubble traps in place even after the ice melted.

After a year of catching bubbles, Walter Anthony could finally calculate how much methane had been bubbling up. And the results, she says, left her “very surprised.”

Scientists had thought that most methane seeped up without forming bubbles. They believed the bubbles held only a little of the gas. But Walter Anthony found that the bubbles held far more methane than what was seeping out other ways. And because scientists had missed those bubbles, they had underestimated how much methane the lakes were belching.

Positive feedback

an aerial image of thermokarst lakes in the Arctic
Thousands of thermokarst lakes (some seen here) dot the Arctic landscape of Alaska, Canada and Russia. These lakes could release large amounts of methane in the coming century.
K. Walter Anthony

Thousands of thermokarst lakes dot the surfaces of Siberia, Alaska and Canada. If Walter Anthony’s measurements hold true for them all, then these lakes could be burping out five times as much methane as people had thought.

“This was certainly a breakthrough,” says David McGuire. “It gave us a much better idea about the importance of thermokarst lakes.” He’s a permafrost scientist who also works at the University of Alaska in Fairbanks.

Once a thermokarst lake has formed, the permafrost beneath can now thaw much more quickly. This is partly because the darker lake absorbs more sunlight than will frozen soil. Walter Anthony and her collaborators estimate that this boost in thawing could cause Arctic permafrost to release twice as much carbon by 2100 as people had predicted. (This “carbon” includes both methane and carbon dioxide.) That, in turn, could cause more warming, more permafrost thawing — and then even more greenhouse gases to be released.

Scientists call this vicious cycle a positive feedback. Some estimates suggest that by 2100, the positive feedback from thawing permafrost could add up to an extra 0.3° Celsius (0.54° Fahrenheit) of global warming.

That may not sound like much. But it could make a big difference if people still hope to keep the Earth from warming more than another 1.5 °C (2.7 °F).

Methane levels in the Earth’s atmosphere have more than doubled since 1700, from fewer than 700 parts per billion to more than 1,800 parts per billion. Most methane comes from human activities such as natural gas drilling, raising cows, the decay of dumped garbage and the intentional burning of forests and cropland.
Graph: 2 Degrees Institute

“It’s sort of like a headwind,” says Steve Frolking. He is a climate scientist at the University of New Hampshire in Durham. “It’s just going to make everything harder,” he says. It would mean people will have to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases by even more.

But even these predictions of carbon-based gases being belched by permafrost don’t take into account the magnitude of methane emerging from Lake Esieh. And Walter Anthony has only just started studying that lake.

Hot spots

a photo of Lake Esieh with brown patches in the middle of the lake
Alaska’s Lake Esieh looks calm, but it bubbles out 2,000 kilograms of methane per day. Brown patches in the lake show where bubbles are rising with such force that they carry mud up from the lake bottom.
K. Walter Anthony

Two members of her team first spotted Lake Esieh from an airplane in April 2017. During several days of flying, they passed over hundreds of lakes. Most were still covered in winter ice. But Melanie Engram and Allen Bondurant noticed that one lake had two large dark spots free of ice. They surmised that these were “hot spots” — regions where gas was bubbling up quickly enough to keep any ice from forming.

Walter Anthony first visited the lake five months later. With a graduate student, her husband and their two young sons, she climbed into a boat and motored four hours up a river to reach the lake. Once there, it was easy to find the methane hot spots.

Paddling a kayak into the bubbling areas was actually “a little bit scary,” says Janelle Sharp, the graduate student on that trip. Not exactly frightening — but strange. “It’s like the water is boiling,” she says. “The bubbles that come up are as big as your head.”

Walter Anthony and her team returned to Lake Esieh in May 2018. They camped on a hillside overlooking one of the bubbling spots. Sharp boated around the lake using sonar, or pulses of sound, to map its bottom. Most of the lake was only about a meter (3 feet) deep. But beneath each hot spot, she found a deep crater in the lake bottom. One of them plunged to a depth of 15 meters (49 feet).

Crumbling hill

Walter Anthony, Sharp and several others returned to the lake again in August 2018. On arriving, they saw new evidence of the permafrost’s relentless thaw. The hillside where they had camped three months earlier was crumbling. Muddy cracks had opened in the ground. Blocks of soil up to 1.5 meters (5 feet) thick had slid off the hillside.

During that trip, Frédéric Thalasso made the first precise gas measurements. He’s a limnologist at the National Polytechnic Institute in Mexico City. He has visited plenty of Arctic lakes with Walter Anthony over the years. He was shocked to find that this one was giving off methane 100 times faster than most others he had seen.

Walter Anthony dated the age of the methane’s source by measuring radioactive carbon-14 in the gas. Carbon-14 builds up in plants while they are alive. After the plants die, their carbon-14 slowly decays into nitrogen. Scientists know how quickly carbon-14 disappears. So by measuring how much of it is left, they can figure out how long ago the plants that collected it had lived.

Walter Anthony’s carbon-14 measurements showed that the methane in Lake Esieh was coming from a very old source. These were rotting plants that had died at least 40,000 years ago — and maybe even millions of years earlier.

She now thinks that the microbes making this methane are eating some sort of fossil fuel. They might live in a coal bed (made of ancient plants) buried somewhere under the lake — below even the permafrost.

That methane would have seeped up through cracks in the rock — until it hit the permafrost above it. The gas couldn’t pass through this frozen barrier. So it collected underneath the frozen soil for tens of thousands of years.

a photo of a hillside eroding and collapsing into mud
Thawing permafrost is causing this hillside to collapse gradually into slumping mud.
K. Walter Anthony

Big boom

This likely changed when the permafrost under Lake Esieh melted all the way to its bottom, Walter Anthony now believes. Suddenly all of that bottled-up methane had a way to escape.

The gas may have burst out violently at first. She says this would explain the two deep craters in the bottom of the lake. If that’s true, then Lake Esieh may not be the only place this has happened.

Scientists have found even larger craters in the permafrost of Siberia. One, discovered in 2014, is 50 meters (about 160 feet) deep. The explosion that ripped this hole in the ground threw chunks of dirt up to 125 meters (400 feet) away. Not everyone agrees on what caused the explosions. But one idea is that they were triggered by methane bursting out from below.

Evidence for similar methane explosions shows up in craters on parts of the Arctic seafloor north of Norway. Found two years ago, some span a kilometer (0.6 mile) across.

What’s important is that some of this methane is coming from a source that scientists had not counted yet. When scientists talk about permafrost carbon, they mean the dead plants buried within the permafrost, which microbes will turn into methane and carbon dioxide.

But Lake Esieh’s methane may have come from an even deeper source, one below the permafrost. And if that’s true, melting permafrost could release far more methane than scientists had suspected.

Big question

Walter Anthony’s discovery at Lake Esieh is “really interesting and fascinating,” says Frolking. He points out that this lake might turn out to be a freak event — the only one of its kind. Methane burping out of a single lake wouldn’t be nearly enough to change the world’s climate.

But if other lakes start acting the same way? “Then it matters a lot,” he says. “It’s huge.”

And Walter Anthony fears this could be the case. Methane may sit trapped under permafrost throughout the Arctic, she says. Much of it comes from deeply buried fossil fuels. The gas would have slowly accumulated for as long as the permafrost was there to stop its rise. In some places, that could be more than a million years.

The question is whether that gas will lead to more lakes like Esieh.

“As permafrost thaws and becomes more like Swiss cheese,” says Walter Anthony, “it’s logical to think we’re going to see more and more of these.”

Power Words

(more about Power Words)

Arctic     A region that falls within the Arctic Circle. The edge of that circle is defined as the northernmost point at which the sun is visible on the northern winter solstice and the southernmost point at which the midnight sun can be seen on the northern summer solstice. The high Arctic is that most northerly third of this region. It’s a region dominated by snow cover much of the year.

atmosphere     The envelope of gases surrounding Earth or another planet.

atom     The basic unit of a chemical element. Atoms are made up of a dense nucleus that contains positively charged protons and uncharged neutrons. The nucleus is orbited by a cloud of negatively charged electrons.

carbon     The chemical element having the atomic number 6. It is the physical basis of all life on Earth. Carbon exists freely as graphite and diamond. It is an important part of coal, limestone and petroleum, and is capable of self-bonding, chemically, to form an enormous number of chemically, biologically and commercially important molecules.

carbon-14 dating     A process to determine the age of material from a once-living object. It is based on comparing the relative share of any carbon-12 present to carbon-14. This ratio changes as radioactive carbon-14 decays and is not replaced. Since the decay of carbon-14 occurs at a steady rate, it provides a way to date how old an object is, but only as long as all of the carbon-14 has not decayed to carbon-12.

carbon dioxide (or CO2)     A colorless, odorless gas produced by all animals when the oxygen they inhale reacts with the carbon-rich foods that they’ve eaten. Carbon dioxide also is released when organic matter burns (including fossil fuels like oil or gas). Carbon dioxide acts as a greenhouse gas, trapping heat in Earth’s atmosphere. Plants convert carbon dioxide into oxygen during photosynthesis, the process they use to make their own food.

climate     The weather conditions that typically exist in one area, in general, or over a long period.

compost     The end product in the breakdown, or decomposition, of leaves, plants, vegetables, manure and other once-living material. Compost is used to enrich garden soil, and earthworms sometimes aid this process.

crater     A large, bowl-shaped cavity in the ground or on the surface of a planet or the moon. They are typically caused by an explosion or the impact of a meteorite or other celestial body. Such an impact is sometimes referred to as a cratering event.

decay     The process (also called “rotting”) by which a dead plant or animal gradually breaks down as it is consumed by bacteria and other microbes. (for radioactive materials) The process whereby a radioactive isotope — which means a physically unstable form of some element — sheds energy and subatomic particles. In time, this shedding will transform the unstable element into a slightly different but stable element. For instance, uranium-238 (which is a radioactive, or unstable, isotope) decays to radium-222 (also a radioactive isotope), which decays to radon-222 (also radioactive), which decays to polonium-210 (also radioactive), which decays to lead-206 — which is stable. No further decay occurs. The rates of decay from one isotope to another can range from timeframes of less than a second to billions of years.

feedback     A response or assessment that follows some a particular act or decision. Or a process or combination of processes that propel or exaggerate a change in some direction. For instance, as the cover of Arctic ice disappears with global warming, less of the sun’s warming energy will be reflected back into space. This will serve to increase the rate of Earth’s warming. That warming might trigger some feedback (like sea-ice melting) that fosters additional warming.

fire     The burning of some fuel, creating a flame that releases light and heat.

flammable     Something that can burn (go up in flames) easily.

football field     The field on which athletes play American football. Owing to its size and familiarity, many people use this field as a measure of how big something is. A regulation field (including its end zones) runs 360 feet (almost 110 meters) long and 160 feet (almost 49 meters) wide.

force     Some outside influence that can change the motion of a body, hold bodies close to one another, or produce motion or stress in a stationary body.

fossil     Any preserved remains or traces of ancient life. There are many different types of fossils: The bones and other body parts of dinosaurs are called “body fossils.” Things like footprints are called “trace fossils.” Even specimens of dinosaur poop are fossils. The process of forming fossils is called fossilization.

fossil fuels     Any fuels — such as coal, petroleum (crude oil) or natural gas — that have developed within the Earth over millions of years from the decayed remains of bacteria, plants or animals.

global warming     The gradual increase in the overall temperature of Earth’s atmosphere due to the greenhouse effect. This effect is caused by increased levels of carbon dioxide, chlorofluorocarbons and other gases in the air, many of them released by human activity.

graduate student     Someone working toward an advanced degree by taking classes and performing research. This work is done after the student has already graduated from college (usually with a four-year degree).

greenhouse gas     A gas that contributes to the greenhouse effect by absorbing heat. Carbon dioxide is one example of a greenhouse gas.

hydrogen     The lightest element in the universe. As a gas, it is colorless, odorless and highly flammable. It’s an integral part of many fuels, fats and chemicals that make up living tissues. It’s made of a single proton (which serves as its nucleus) orbited by a single electron.

limnology     A branch of ecology that studies inland waters, including lakes, streams and groundwater. A scientist who works in this field is called a limnologist.

methane     A hydrocarbon with the chemical formula CH4 (meaning there are four hydrogen atoms bound to one carbon atom). It’s a natural constituent of what’s known as natural gas. It’s also emitted by decomposing plant material in wetlands and is belched out by cows and other ruminant livestock. From a climate perspective, methane is 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide is in trapping heat in Earth’s atmosphere, making it a very important greenhouse gas.

microbe     Short for microorganism. A living thing that is too small to see with the unaided eye, including bacteria, some fungi and many other organisms such as amoebas. Most consist of a single cell.

molecule     An electrically neutral group of atoms that represents the smallest possible amount of a chemical compound. Molecules can be made of single types of atoms or of different types. For example, the oxygen in the air is made of two oxygen atoms (O2), but water is made of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom (H2O).

organic     (in chemistry) An adjective that indicates something is carbon-containing; also a term that relates to the basic chemicals that make up living organisms.

permafrost     Soil that remains frozen for at least two consecutive years. Such conditions typically occur in polar climates, where average annual temperatures remain close to or below freezing.

PhD     (also known as a doctorate) A type of advanced degree offered by universities — typically after five or six years of study — for work that creates new knowledge. People qualify to begin this type of graduate study only after having first completed a college degree (a program that typically takes four years of study).

potent     An adjective for something (like a germ, poison, drug or acid) that is very strong or powerful.

pressure     Force applied uniformly over a surface, measured as force per unit of area.

radiation     (in physics) One of the three major ways that energy is transferred. (The other two are conduction and convection.) In radiation, electromagnetic waves carry energy from one place to another. Unlike conduction and convection, which need material to help transfer the energy, radiation can transfer energy across empty space.

radioactive     An adjective that describes unstable elements, such as certain forms (isotopes) of uranium and plutonium. Such elements are said to be unstable because their nucleus sheds energy that is carried away by photons and/or and often one or more subatomic particles. This emission of energy is by a process known as radioactive decay.

Siberia     A region in northern Asia, almost all of which falls within Russia. This land takes its name from the language of the Tatar people, where Siber means sleeping land. This region is vast. It has become famous for its long, harsh winters, where temperatures can fall to −68° Celsius (−90° Fahrenheit).

sonar     A system for the detection of objects and for measuring the depth of water. It works by emitting sound pulses and measuring how long it takes the echoes to return.

spruce     Any of several dozen species of coniferous evergreen tree.

thermokarst     Arctic land whose surface develops pits and valleys as the underlying permafrost melts. These depressions can collect snow or ice melt, forming shallow lakes (thermokarst lakes). As the lake water appears dark, it tends to collect lots of solar energy, warming the ground around it even more.

tundra     A cold, usually lowland area in far northern regions. The subsoil is permanently frozen. In summer, a tundra's top layer of soil thaws and can support low-growing mosses, lichens, grasses, shrubs and trees (some only a few centimeters high).


Journal: K. Walter Anthony et al. 21st-century modeled permafrost carbon emissions accelerated by abrupt thaw beneath lakes. Nature Communications. Vol. 9, August 15, 2018, p. 3262. doi: 10.1038/s41467-018-05738-9.

Journal: D. Olefeldt et al. Circumpolar distribution and carbon storage of thermokarst landscapes. Nature Communications. Vol. 7, October 11, 2016, p. 13043. doi: 10.1038/ncomms13043.

Journal: M.O. Leibman et al. New permafrost feature - deep crater in central Yamal (west Siberia, Russia) as a response to local climate fluctuations. Geography, Environment, Sustainability. Vol. 7, No. 4, 2014, p. 68. doi: 10.24057/2071-9388-2014-7-4-68-79.

Journal: K.M. Walter Anthony et al. A shift of thermokarst lakes from carbon sources to sinks during the Holocene epoch. Nature. Vol. 511, July 24, 2014, p. 452. doi: 10.1038/nature13560.

Journal: K. Walter Anthony et al. Geologic methane seeps along boundaries of Arctic permafrost thaw and melting glaciers. Nature Geoscience. Vol. 5, May 20, 2012, p. 419. doi: 10.1038/ngeo1480.

Journal: K.M. Walter, L.C. Smith and F.S. Chapin. Methane bubbling from northern lakes: present and future contributions to the global methane budget. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A. Vol. 365, May 18, 2007, p. 1657. doi: 10.1098/rsta.2007.2036.

Journal: K.M. Walter et al. Methane bubbling from Siberian thaw lakes as a positive feedback to climate warming. Nature. Vol 443, September 7, 2006, p. 71. doi: 10.1038/nature05040.

Further Reading